Brown and Caldwell Home Page
Technical Papers RECENT PAPERS    ALL PAPERS

Brown and Caldwell engineers and scientists are technical and thought leaders in the environmental sector. Meet the people who have been advancing innovation for more than 70 years.
Author      Title/Abstract      


Regulatory Update Needed
Author: Woodie M. Muirhead, Rob Baur, Mary Darr, Greg Farmer, Jose Jimenez, Wayne Schutz and Ron Taylor
Date: 1/209
WE&T, Vol. 21, No. 1, January 2009, pp. 45-49

The 36-year-old Secondary Treatment regulation (40 CFR 133.102) has little relevance to wastewater treatment facilities that must meet stringent nitrogen and phosphorus limits. Advanced wastewater treatment facilities consistently reduce effluent 5-day biochemical oxygen demand (BoD) and total suspended solids (TSS) concentrations to less than 30 mg/L. However, permit writers lack the flexibility to exclude requirements for these parameters from national Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (nPDES) permits. A new regulatory framework is needed for the following practical, legal, and financial reasons: o When a treatment facility meets stringent nutrient limits, it also meets BoD, carbonaceous BoD (cBoD), and TSS limits because of design and operating requirements. Including technology-based limits in nPDES permits for nutrient-removal facilities does not benefit the environment, scientists, regulators, or permittees. 0 Redundant permit limits subject permittees to double or even triple legal jeopardy. If a plant fails to meet a 30-mg/L cBoD effluent limit, it also will fail to meet a 5.0-mg/L ammonia–nitrogen limit. If the plant fails to meet a 30-mg/L TSS limit, it also will fail to meet a 0.5-mg/L total phosphorus limit. In both cases, one event would prompt two (or more) violations. o Sampling and analyzing BoD, cBoD, and TSS every day or even 3 days a week is not an effective use of valuable laboratory resources. Such resources could be better used for process control. Eliminating BoD and TSS limits for these facilities would not affect receiving-water quality, but it would reduce costly, unnecessary monitoring.

This library contains published materials for which copyrights may be owned by entities other than Brown and Caldwell, but which are stored for limited uses by BC employees. Technical papers authored by BC employees generally may be printed and shared electronically with clients and prospective clients outside BC. Technical papers cannot be sold, and technical papers shared outside BC must have proper attribution of the original sponsoring organization or conference where the paper was presented. This attribution is embedded in each technical paper file when it is loaded into this library. Published articles from magazines or trade journals which are stored in this library are FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY and SHOULD NOT be distributed to clients or others outside BC, without express permission of the copyright owner. For questions regarding copyrights associated with any document in this library, or questions regarding copyrights in general, contact the Legal Department.